/mg/ - Monster Girls

Main monster girl board

Mode: Reply
Name
Subject
Message

Max message length: 20000

Files

Max file size: 30.00 MB

Max files: 5

E-mail
Password

(used to delete files and postings)

Misc

Remember to follow the rules

[ Return / Catalog / Bottom ]

Sorter and Tier list for MGE Anonymous 04/20/2025 (Sun) 02:52:00 No. 16067
Blatantly copying a thread from Smug. Because its fun! Sorter: https://kikasuru.github.io/mge-charasort/ Tier list(slightly out of date): https://tiermaker.com/create/mge-344539 Doing the whole sorter takes like an hour (1000+ choices) so take your time, or limit the species. But doing the whole thing gets more fun the deeper you go. Its also neat seeing the end result and ponder your taste in context of it.
>>28380 Not him, I've placed man eaters high as well but especially saccophytes because on top of this >>28388 I just like it when their looks are deceiving to how much of a predator they are. Gives them an element of mystery to me. I also like quite Taisuis! They're slimes that make you go crazy and yet they act like it's not a big deal. Definitely mysterious.
>>28384 Who the fuck looks at a humanized KELP and goes >Wife ? Well I guess now we have the answer
>>28384 no hate but you are a strange specimen. why would you be ok with imps and devils, but demons and succubi are a no go?
>>28436 not him, but kelps have some appeal. they are super clingy and can change their body based on hydration, thats a pretty big plus to someone with witches and baphomets in high tiers.
(4.35 MB 1140x2196 my-image.png)
>>28371 And now my tier list. Its a little different, but its also correct.
>>28456 >why would you be ok with imps and devils, but demons and succubi are a no go? I've developed strong impressions of succubi and imps over decades of consuming countless hentai games and doujins. Imps are treasures, succubi are scary. Dark Priest is getting nun boosted because evil nun scenes are usually god tier. In retrospect, the succubi in escape could have been put in forced (except Alp, he stays). I was a bit harsh dumping them all in escape next to the slimes. I literally never jerk off to slimes. >>28436 They are ocean monsters (big plus, I like the ocean), they have human legs/thighs, they can shift between loli form and adult form (holy shit!!!), they have long dark wavy hair(kelp) and gloomy disposition, they like piggy back rides, and they can be eaten or used as a cooking ingredient. They're a contender for #1 monster girl.
>>28534 >they can be eaten or used as a cooking ingredient Wtf don't eat your wife
>>28499 Species wise you like many of the same ones as I do, but judging by the rest of the list you aren't very much of a loli enjoyer. Are you sure you aren't missing out?
>>28590 i am very much not a fan, i find it gross. i know theres the whole thing of theyre actually an adult or whatever but its just repulsive to me
>>28597 same anon, i feel the need to clarify that i am a hypocrite because i like the idea of being de-aged/turned into a shota
I shall create a new age to shake the foundations of heaven and earth.
>>29355 the list is so good minus a few things, but why apophis in the lowest tier? :(
>>29394 It's nothing more than a joke. My wife being a Pharaoh as she is, wouldn't enjoy the idea of me putting an Apophis in any other tier. Otherwise, grape snek is fine.
>>29355 Fine taste in high powerlevel girls, I'm a fan of them too.
>>29400 Thanks. Something about a girl so powerful she could crush me, but instead chooses to love me tender is just so wonderful.
>>29402 To be fair the majority of monsters could probably do that
>>29429 nah I can take 'em gimme a werewolf to fight
>>29430 >Mom's basement dweller with a stick >vs >Miss Werewolf, predator of men, hungry for a mate to lead her pack Place your bets
>>29431 excuse me I'll have you know I own several non-wallhanger shit swords
>>29431 >Stick I'm a gentleman who dual-wields and has a respect for the past. It's a stick AND a news paper.
(257.27 KB 1016x717 phone screenshot.jpg)
I did the sorter a long time ago, but forgot to post it here. I wonder what my type actually is given the outliers I have.
>>29471 >Candlegeist, armor, automaton, lich and mantis. in the top 10 >but also thunderbird, rata and myconid >and also Aside from Kiki and Nightgaunts being outliers, it's clear what kind of monsters you like.
>>29472 I can kinda see Nightgaunt as the bridge between Thunderbird and Rata and the first category, she's kind of like in between them. I'd argue the Myconid's the outlier... but then I saw Genie and Panda in 11 and 12. Kiki's kinda similar to Automaton too. Mamonos have a lot more in common than you think!
>>29398 thats completely fair, i didnt pick up on that. id rather you have apophis in the bottom tier than be a double agent. we have enough of those.
>>29431 nah, he'd win. my money is on the basement dweller.
>>29471 unfathomably based
>>29472 Kiki is just top tier housewife. Night gaunts kind of fit into the same "cold on the outside, but loving in private" category other than the addition of transforming into her suit. Either I forgot about it, or I was completely okay with being attached 24/7 as long as she fit the archetype. It's kind of like a reverse living armor. >>29474 Not sure how night gaunt bridges those two, nor how myconid relates to genie and panda. They seem very different personality wise.
>>29552 Keep in mind this is just how I read them. Feel free to disagree. Night Gaunts are described as cold and malicious, and they'll actually attack you quite openly... until it backfires on them just like how Thunderbird and Ratatoskr's plans seem to "backfire". Either way, they started as mean but will open up to you due to circumstances in how they hunt. What I meant by bridging the gap would be the cold part, they seem like the more silent type like the first category, but at the same time they're also quite spicy and mean like the second. For Myconid and Panda, they're both quite simplistic in nature. Both of them are very laidback and would probably wish to do nothing other than sex with (You). I can see them as being very playful. Genies are only somewhat related. She will try to trick you into having as much sex as she wants, so she's playful in a mischievous sense, also sharing a few traits with the second category too.
>>29564 > started as mean but will open up to you due to circumstances in how they hunt I didn't realize this connection at first, but I can see it. Though in the case of ratatoskr, I saw her more as a brat that you need to take care of because they can't handle the consequences of their actions. Being attracted to mean girls was not what I expected, but it does match the dynamic that I like, replacing the aloofness with maliciousness but still keeping a side to discover behind closed doors. >I can see them as being very playful. Genies are only somewhat related Makes sense. I do think all three somewhat match the "opening up" in some way. Myconids bounce around, but, rather than their plans backfiring, they do change their disposition after husband hunting. Pandas, on the other hand, have their mischievous nature toned down towards being playful, but still trick people by disguising it as play. One that eventually awakens a primal need for a different type of play. This whole "changes when they find their husband" could be descriptive of all mamono, but as you've said, mamonos have a lot more in common than you think. It probably helps that they're both described as very cuddly, but probably not enough to displace my bias. >Keep in mind this is just how I read them. Feel free to disagree. It's always nice to see a different reading. Different perspectives help deepen one's understanding by revealing something the original person may not have seen, like in this case.
I dont know why, but i get the compulsion to keep doing the sort over and over again. I always feel like I've done it wrong somehow.
(418.46 KB 1524x896 sorterof2025.png)
heres my list
>>29817 you are a cuddleslut
>>29819 Then the siths should be much higher.
>>29819 i like soft women to hug and cuddle life is hard but wife is soft
>>29820 >wurm >bogey >krampus >holstaur >armor >yukionna >yeti it's damning. some people just aren't furries that anon is going to get mindbroken by hugs alone >>29821 understandable
>>29508 Exactly. An unhappy Pharaoh is a major cause for pelvic damage and irrevocable mummy curses. You have to be careful with these things. Then again, being a bit of a brat and rage baiting the harem would be a good idea every now and then. It would make for fun times if I called my mighty Pharaoh an Enshi rather than a Neb-tawy. Or stating that the Pyramid she just built was made using slave labor like the ones of old. That might cause her to get confused for just a second, then be doubly angry for both a wrong approach to Kemetology, and a wrong approach to her own domains.
>>29817 Good taste, anon.
(382.98 KB 520x993 rdrama mge rankings 2.png)
(780.28 KB 1097x761 rdrama mge rankings 3.png)
(1.38 MB 1447x992 rdrama mge rankings 1.png)
>>31461 >hetero male >fricker >alp #1 hmmm...
>>31461 >what the fuck is rdrama <clicks the link >immediate giant tranny flag >rules literally say supporting free speech is an immediate ban >also prohibits all the usual "phobias" that lefties hate >that includes furphobia How about you kill yourself for sharing such trash?
decided to redo a sorter run and it seems a bunch of images are dead
>>31467 Even if you're gay I dont get how alp can be number 1 for anyone, they don't have a lot going for them. i dont even hate alps theyre just kinda nothing.
>>32109 if I had to guess it's some "trans affirmation woohoo" weirdo that puts that as his primary criteria I am at a choice in the sorter where I just cannot justify picking either option and I'm not sure what to do. the urge to hit "tie" is overwhelming but I must persist in not picking tie ever these low-rank "which one do you dislike less" matches are so much harder than the "which one do you like more" matches
>>32109 I'm neither gay nor a tranny lover IRL, but Alps have that excitement/forbidden fruit effect without its consequences or unsavory aspects like, a dick or axe wound down there
(4.34 MB 1140x2287 my-image.png)
80% finished no-ties sorter redo save disappeared for some reason, so I did a tier list instead since it's fast not sorted within tiers
>>33076 Good taste! My only real compliant is the abyssal in the 2nd to lowest tier, but I get it. I also might steal this tiering name format for my own.
>>33076 Lot of fluff high up, good to see the ren xiomao getting some love. You seem to generaly like active and straightforward girls.
>>33247 >2nd to lowest It may as well be the lowest since the Alp tier is practically a joke at this point.
>>33486 i will give her all the good graces i can
(891.91 KB 1200x1200 CTXXwzsUkAAmH_-.png)
>>33247 I'd be fine with 'flayers and 'gaunts if not for the whole thing, really. just don't like it. forced mental changes are also way out of my zone for things I'd actually like to live through. it can be hot in porn but to me? hell nah that's scary I do think it's better when tiers are descriptive. letter grading doesn't really mean anything without a scoring system >>33256 >You seem to generaly like active and straightforward girls guilty as charged panders are big cuties, no idea why no one really talks about em. run-ins with them write themselves, great design, absolutely zero weird stuff. and look at all the fluff >>33486 it is what it is, I'm even less into traps than I am into loli. maybe not less than I am into being a spiderbutt or crotchsquid, but at least a nacho is cute herself. just not something I'd ever want to deal with

[ Return / Catalog / Top ]
Delete
Report